COVER: Gene Colan
THE COVER:
We start things off with a cover by one of my personal top ten Bronze Age artists, Gene Colan. I have to admit that I don't like this cover as much as I feel I SHOULD, but it seems like there's a bit too much wasted space. The terrified face of the victim is great, but it's sort of hidden away down in the corner. Not a BAD cover (I don't think I've ever seen anything by Gene Colan I'd call bad), but it could have been better. Let's get inside!
THE STORIES:
Although this comic's title and cover leans heavy into "The Pit and the Pendulum", there's also adaptations of "The Tell-Tale Heart" and "The Cask of Amontillado" in here by the same writer, but with different artists. Let's give them each a turn. . .
THE PIT AND THE PENDULUM
SCRIPT: Edgar Allan Poe, adapted by Don McGregor
PENCILS: Rudy Mesina
An unnamed man is brutally tortured by the Spanish Inquisition after being sentenced to death. Relying on his wits and pure determination to live, he manages to avoid a terrible fate several times before being rescued.
Widely-regarded as one of Poe's greatest stories, this short tale of terror and torment is a simple one at heart, with no named characters and a pure focus on the torture endured and the mental toll it takes on the main character. This is actually one of the best adaptations of the story I've seen.
Don McGregor maintains the rambling first-person narrative of the original tale, condensing it down to the bare essence needed to translate into comic form. Rudy Mesina backs the writing up with dark, horrific art that perfectly captures the desperate, helpless tone of the story.
A simply fantastic re-telling of a classic tale!
NEXT!
THE TELL-TALE HEART
SCRIPT: Edgar Allan Poe, adapted by Don McGregor
PENCILS: Yong Montano
After a caretaker murders an elderly man, he cleverly hides the body, but while being interviewed by the police, he is so tormented by the perceived beating of the dead man's heart that he confesses his crime.
Don McGregor knocks it out of the park a second time by stripping down the original narrative JUST enough to adapt it to comic form, while artist Yong Montano provides some fantastic visuals that take us on the narrator's journey to madness through some really interesting panel forms and layouts.
Together, the creative team gives the reader a dark trip into a twisted mind that makes even a story as well-known as this one a gripping read! Very nicely done.
AND FINALLY. . .
THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO
SCRIPT: Edgar Allan Poe, adapted by Don McGregor
PENCILS: Michael Golden
After being somehow insulted, the injured man lures the perpetrator deep into a family vault, where he walls him up alive. . .
Once again, Don McGregor strips a classic tale down to the terrifying essence, taking just enough of the original narrative to adapt the story to comic form, and leaving the rest to the artist.
I mentioned above that this is Michael Golden's first published comic work, and as you can see from the page scan above, he arrived with his unique style already fully-formed! Often, when you see an artist's early work compared to their later, there can be a significant difference. This is not the case here.
Golden's signature realistic-yet-exaggerated and darkly-inked style perfectly compliments the horrific tale of a man lured to his death. He deftly takes over where McGregor leaves off, providing the reader with a fantastic rendering of what normally must be created in the mind's eye.
Overall, a practically perfect comic adaptation of what is already a practically perfect story.
CONCLUSION
When I was ten years old, my introduction to the world of horror was with a gigantic illustrated and annotated volume of Edgar Allan Poe's stories that I got for a Christmas present. The Pit and The Pendulum and The Cask of Amontillado were two stories that gripped my young attention , and they remain two of my favorite stories today. Both of them short and simple, but terrifying in a way that no vampire or ghost story could ever be.
This comic adaptation of three stories that I have read and enjoyed MANY times are of such quality in both writing and art that they once again gripped my imagination and seemed almost new!
Bottom line. . .if you are a fan of Edgar Allan Poe or horror comics (or both), then you should have this comic in your collection. Despite being Michael Golden's first published comic work, it's not anywhere close to being "valuable" to collectors, so copies can be found cheap. . .I paid one lousy buck for mine. Plus I see it's on ComiXology, so there's that as well.
If you're looking for some creepy Halloween comic reading, you can't do much better than this.
Up Next. . .
It's time to invite a Werewolf to this Halloween Party!
Marvel's Werewolf By Night #11 from 1973.
Be there or be square!