feature requests

comic reader vs. comic collector

  • batfan | Male | san jose, ca

"if he dies....he dies! i cannot be defeated!"

March 2023




comic reader vs. comic collector

940 views • Jun 16, '08 • (7) Comments

To me this is a very different thing. comic readers actually read comics!!! comic collectors just have them for investment or art. collecting started in the late sixties but didn't catch on until the 80's which led to the crash of the comic industry.

i myself am a comic reader AND collector.

i read all my comics especially my grails. i love the stories in the GA/ early SA comics. you can see the characters evolve over the years. like batman, wouldn't hesitate to shoot a gun to kill in the early detective comics but then robin came along..... or superman in early actions couldn't fly, he leaped.

i collect not for the value but for the art. i love the art. that's also why i hate 90's comics, the art sucks. Liefeld is the worst of all of the sucky artists out there. schomurg is to all artists in the comic industry.the great covers evolved over the years but are still evident. the era i least like for cover art besides the 90's is the 70's. it didn't do much for me. it's still alright though.

my choice in buying a comic is: is the story good? is the art good? if answer to one is yes i will purchase, if the answer to both is yes than it will be easier for me to purchase, if the answer is no to both i won't. some comics don't apply, like the top 20 golden (even though i've read the top 20 golden and say both story and art is great, especially my Tec' #33!)

there is no concept of actually reading or enjoying your comics anymore. maybe this is only for the collectors of older comics like myself. people should enjoy what they are collecting. an example: there is an english guy, ian levine (for anyone who knows him), he has the most complete dc collection there is. EVERY single DC comic available. he knows everything about DC but has Never read any of the comics. then there is this other guy, forget his name, he has literally the best collection ever!! ultra HG examples of every comic from 1933 to 1969! he was collecting since he was little in the 50's (the way people do now). he would advertise that he would buy or dispose of anyone's used or unwanted comics in a newspaper ad! Action 1. Tec' 27, marvel 1 in 7.0 or higher! he doesn't care about value and keeping them in the ultra HG. he reads all of them! he enjoys them. and even though he uses them they stay in excellent condition!

i also am happy when i see a person in my class reading comics. it shows at least the industry isn't dying because the lack of readers. i see even the older more mature sophmores, juniors, and seniors in my high school reading the latest issue of cap america or iron man. sometimes i wonder if it's because of the movie hype but will soon dismiss it because at least they are keeping the business alive.

  • Jun 16, '08 by jkoswald's avatar jkoswald
  • i buy new comics for reading and for the artwork....anything old i get is for collecting...(i intend to read those, but only when i have a complete set to read...and even then i wont be reading out of the books)
  • Jun 16, '08 by 1573's avatar 1573
  • i'm both a reader and a collector.
    i can say that i have read everything in my collection.
    i may not remember everything but i have read it.
  • Jun 16, '08 by tt_cook1963's avatar tt_cook1963
  • I was a reader back in the day. i still read new issues when i get a chance. But with a 5 year old i tend not to read older books i buy cause he wants to read them as well. With past experience watching a vf-nm book go to a f- in 2 seconds, my fault for leaving it on the coffee table to go to the bathroom, my son just wanting to be like dad pick it up and open and pretend to read it, i dont read all the older books i buy now. I think i lean more to the collector side of the issue now. And i can honestly say i HAVE NOT read everthing in my collection.
  • Jun 16, '08 by dough boy's avatar dough boy
  • I am like tt. I read everything I buy. If I don't like it I stop buying it.

    Now I won't read older books...to afraid to. However, I am considering buy an annual Marvel Digital subscription so that I can read the old ones without damage to my collection. (Plus actually read the old ones that I cannot and likely will not ever be able to afford).

    I have also just starting last week stopped buying reprints and variants. I won't do it any more. I will wait until they are in the dollar bin and instead use my money to get my back issues.
  • Jun 16, '08 by 1573's avatar 1573
  • yeah, i had to stop picking up every variant cover.
    i was going way over my comic budget (usually 12-15 books a month).
    even now i have a hard time deciding what needs to get cut from monthly list.

    it's even harder to decide what goes and what stays whenever i thin out the collection.
    i refer to this as "purging the collection".
    not fun, not fun at all.
  • Jun 16, '08 by batfan's avatar batfan
  • i have never been a variant person myself. if i like the way the variant looks i will either wait till it is not hot anymore to buy it or somehow get it for cheap. i will never buy a regular issue and a variant. no point to it.
  • Jun 22, '08 by georgiafan87's avatar georgiafan87
  • I find myself a Reader and Collecter basically I read every comic I get at least once, sometimes more then once if I need to catch-up on a story. I collect some comics just for the art too, I read them but if the story was trash, I still keep it in my collection for the cover art. Old Jack Kirby art is my favorite, I would love to get my hands on some of his older comic art. For most part though I read,then bag and board and keep in my collection.
World Community Grid Logo
ComicBookRealm.com: 67 years, 116 days, 23 hours of Run Time
Help projects like: Smash Childhood Cancer, OpenZika, Help Stop TB, FightAIDS@Home - Phase 2, Outsmart Ebola Together, Mapping Cancer Markers, FightAIDS@Home
Join World Community Grid today!
  • Newest
  • Viz Media's Crazy Food Truck Soft Cover # 3
  • IDW Publishing's Earthdivers: Kill Columbus Issue # 6c
  • DC Comics's Milestone 30th Anniversary Special Issue # 1c
  • Frew Publications Pty. Ltd.'s The Phantom Issue # 1831