feature requests

Longbox Junk Halloween DCU Halloween Special 2010

  • atom | Male | Utah

"I have a lot of issues. . ."

I write comic book reviews that NOBODY has ever asked for!

July 2019

SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031 

Archives

Tags

Ah. . .Halloween.  I love it!

It's that one special time of year when Wal-Mart shamelessly displays "Naughty Nurse" outfits that would usually only be found in somewhat sketchy stores on the outskirts of town. . .and one aisle over it's a winter wonderland of  pre-lit plastic Christmas trees in every color of the rainbow!

To which I can only quote the great Will 'Wicky, Wicky, Wild Wild West' Smith and say: "Welcome to Earth!"

ANYWAY. . .

I've been having a bit of Halloween fun here at Longbox Junk, starting things off by reading and reviewing a set of DC Universe Halloween Special one shots.  The 2008 Special was disappointing.  The 2009 Special was a definite improvement, but still only half the book was any good.

The comic at hand this time is the DC Universe Halloween Special 2010.Will it continue the upward curve?  Let's find out!

DC UNIVERSE

HALLOWEEN SPECIAL

2010

Only 6 stories this time out.  Let's break it on down and hope they're good ones. . .

BATMAN IN TRICK FOR THE SCARECROW

SCRIPT: Billy Tucci

PENCILS: Billy Tucci

Scarecrow finds himself in need of rescue by Batman after being captured by two young boys on Halloween night.

The 2010 Halloween Special gets off on a good foot by putting the fantastic art of Billy Tucci right up front, along with a pretty good little story that is a direct sequel to Tucci's entry in the 2009 DCU Halloween Special.  This little tale has humor, heart, and a Batman who actually smiles!  A solid 4 OUT OF 5.

Batman on a roof framed by the full moon.  Classic!

 

BATMAN & ROBIN AND I. . .VAMPIRE IN ROBIN THE VAMPIRE SLAYER

SCRIPT: Joe Harris

PENCILS: Lee Garbett

Batman (Dick Grayson) and Robin (Damian Wayne) enter into an uneasy alliance with Vampire Andrew Bennett (I. . .Vampire) in order to take down a nest of vampires in Gotham City that are part of the Cult of The Blood Red Moon.

Another really good little story.  It's mostly Batman & Robin fighting vampires, but there's a bit of a twist (The cult is actually holding Andrew Bennett prisoner and he sort of tricked Batman & Robin into helping him escape) and it's well written with a spotlight on the adversarial relationship between Dick Grayson and Damian Wayne that made their time as Batman & Robin so interesting to a lot of fans.  The art is also perfect for this story, being dark and strongly-inked with brilliant splashes of color in all the right places.  Another solid 4 OUT OF 5.

Batman and Robin jumping through windows never gets old!

 

THE FLASH AND FRANKENSTEIN IN TIME OR YOUR LIFE

SCRIPT: Alex Segura

PENCILS: Kennith Loh

When Iris Allen's new assistant turns out to be a soul-sucking vampiric creature during a Halloween party, Frankenstein shows up to help The Flash defeat her.

This one's a bit of a mess.  Frankenstein just sort of shows up for no reason.  He fights Flash for a bit during a cliche "heroes fight until they realize they need to team up against the real enemy", and then Frankenstein just sort of wanders off at the end.  The art is pretty good, but I'm puzzled as to why this story exists, other than. . .Frankenstein and Flash teamup, hooray?  2 OUT OF 5

Frankenstein with a shotgun? I can dig it.

 

WONDER WOMAN AND DEADMAN IN A NIGHT TO REMEMBER

SCRIPT: Vinton Heuk

PENCILS: Dean Zachary

Deadman and Wonder Woman accidentally run into each other and team up to take down Felix Faust before he can summon a Godlike creature from another dimension.

After a very strong start, this Halloween Special is sliding downhill.  This story isn't bad so much as it feels forced and unnecessary.  I wondered when Deadman was going to show up in one of these Halloween Specials, but he just seems wasted in this "Two heroes accidentally find themselves at the same villain lair and team up" cliche punch-fest with a schmear of Cthulhu on it.  The art is very nicely done. . .so there's that at least.  2 OUT OF 5

Well, at least the pictures are nice. . .

 

TEEN TITANS AND KLARION THE WITCH BOY IN MEDUSA NON GRATA

SCRIPT: Bryan Q. Miller

PENCILS: Trevor McCarthy

Miss Martian and Blue Beetle have their Halloween trick or treating ruined when Klarion the Witch Boy comes to Earth and starts turning people into stone.

The downward slide of this Halloween Special continues here as we get another punch-fest with only a tenuous Halloween connection backed up by some utterly average comic art.  There's a couple of funny moments, but otherwise this only deserves a 2 OUT OF 5.

Klarion's evil kitty is the best part of this story. . .

 

And finally. . .

SUPERMAN AND THE DEMON IN FEARS OF STEEL

SCRIPT: Brian Keene

PENCILS: Stephen Thompson

The Demon Etrigan helps save Superman's soul when another demon torments the hero with visions of his worst fears.

*sigh*

Bad, derivative and cliche story.  Bad, clunky and sloppy art.

Bad finish for this comic.  Just. . .bad.  1 OUT OF 5

Yeah. . .that's what my reaction was when I saw this art.  And this is one of the good panels.

 

CONCLUSION

I liked it a lot when I saw this Halloween Special only had 6 stories.  I thought that maybe with less stories, there would be less filler.  And then when it started off with two great little stories in a row, I was like "HELL YEAH!".  But then the rest of the comic slid downhill fast and it was like getting a goddamn apple in my candy bucket.

At least DC only charged $4.99 + tax for this one.  It's still about three bucks more than what it's worth for 2 good stories and some decent art.  Pretty disappointing.  I don't even want to read the next one.

Up Next. . .

How about I give the DC Halloween superhero anthologies a break (I still have 2 more to go) and continue the spooky fun with the comic sequel that nobody ever asked for to the unwanted sequel of a classic horror movie?

IDW's The Fly: Outbreak 5 issue mini OR (as I like to call it) The Fly III.

Wait.  You didn't know there was a Fly II? SURPRISE!

Be there or be square.

 

  • 287 days ago by edgos2's avatar edgos2
  • Again, I appreciate the breakdown of stories. Today I was able to pick up the Halloween Walmart/DC 100 page Swamp Thing Giant for $4.99. Just one new story, while the rest are reprints, and possibly some of the ones you've covered here over the last three days. Hopefully the better ones! Thanks for such entertaining blog posts!
  • 281 days ago by Spector's avatar Spector
  • Looks like a really cool ish. Thanks for giving up the skinny. I really hadn't seen any of the DC Halloween specials you posted up, so it was really neat for me. I saw some sort of DC scary/halloween special type book in my LCS today. It had a Batman story in it, I do remember. I checked inside just to be sure it was all new stories, and not reprints, and they were all new. Unfortunately, the book price was $9.99. (A 100 pager I do believe) So I ended up putting it back and getting a couple extra other books.
World Community Grid Logo
ComicBookRealm.com: 52 years, 75 days, 17 hours of Run Time
Help projects like: Smash Childhood Cancer, OpenZika, Help Stop TB, FightAIDS@Home - Phase 2, Outsmart Ebola Together, Mapping Cancer Markers, FightAIDS@Home
Join World Community Grid today!
  • Newest
  • Titan Comics's Doctor Who: 13th Doctor Issue # 10b
  • Marvel Comics's Marvel Comics Presents Issue # 6 - 2nd print
  • Chapter House Publishing Inc.'s Marvel Mini-Books Issue Green Spots
  • Rebellion's Tammy and Jinty: Special 2019 Special # 1